Back to all posts

David Jones Enters Voluntary Administration: What Happens to Its Leases, Stock and Store Assets?

Samantha Lo

Written by

Samantha Lo

The entry of David Jones into voluntary administration and receivership raises questions that extend well beyond the future of the retail business itself.

For commercial landlords, suppliers and other businesses dealing with David Jones, the immediate concerns include unpaid rent, bank guarantees, ownership of stock and the treatment of store assets.

While the circumstances are particular to David Jones, the issues are relevant to any business dealing with a financially distressed tenant, customer or supplier.

From a property and commercial law perspective, there are three areas worth examining.

1. Commercial leases: What happens to the landlords?

For shopping centre landlords, one of the immediate concerns is unpaid rent and the potential closure of stores.

The reported figures make for an interesting comparison.

Scentre Group reportedly holds approximately $30 million in bank guarantees attributable to David Jones' Westfield stores, equivalent to around 8 months' gross rent.

Vicinity Centres, meanwhile, has reported approximately $2.2 million in unpaid rent across its four David Jones stores, with no bank guarantees held for those stores.

The difference highlights the importance of negotiating appropriate security arrangements at the outset of a commercial lease.

A bank guarantee is more than a box to tick before a tenant takes possession. Its amount, wording, expiry date and the circumstances in which it can be called upon can make a significant difference to a landlord's financial exposure.

But security is only part of the picture.

Can a landlord terminate a lease simply because the tenant enters voluntary administration?

Not necessarily.

The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) contains restrictions on enforcing certain contractual rights triggered by a company's insolvency. These are commonly referred to as the ipso facto stay provisions.

In addition, during voluntary administration, statutory restrictions may apply to a landlord's ability to recover possession of premises occupied by the company.

This does not mean landlords have no rights. However, the distinction between an insolvency-related trigger and an independent contractual default is important. The terms of the lease, the nature of the breach and the applicable statutory restrictions all need to be considered before enforcement action is taken.

There is also the question of what happens when a store eventually closes.

Who is responsible for removing the fit-out, repairing damage and reinstating the premises? What happens to outstanding make-good obligations?

For landlords, these issues can have a substantial financial impact, particularly where the premises involve extensive retail fit-outs.

2. Supplier arrangements: Can suppliers recover their stock?

Another issue arising from the administration is the position of suppliers seeking to recover goods held in David Jones stores.

The answer is not simply a matter of identifying which supplier delivered the goods. It depends on the underlying supply arrangement and the ownership position.

Consider three common arrangements:

Outright sale

Where goods have been sold outright and ownership has passed to the retailer, the supplier may simply be an unsecured creditor for any outstanding purchase price, unless it has other enforceable security.

Consignment

Goods supplied on consignment may remain the supplier's property, depending on the terms and operation of the arrangement.

Retention of title

A retention-of-title (ROT) clause is intended to preserve the supplier's ownership of goods until payment is received.

However, including an ROT clause in a supply agreement does not automatically guarantee that the supplier can recover its goods in an insolvency.

Under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA), a retention-of-title arrangement will generally give rise to a security interest. The supplier should ensure that the interest is properly registered on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR), with the correct grantor details and collateral description.

The timing and accuracy of registration matter. An unperfected security interest may be vulnerable to vesting in the grantor upon insolvency under the PPSA.

There is also a practical consideration. Suppliers should not assume they can simply enter a store and remove goods. The statutory restrictions applying during voluntary administration, together with the administrator's control of the company's affairs, need to be considered.

For businesses supplying goods on credit, this is a reminder to review both the wording of supply agreements and the effectiveness of their PPSR registrations.

3. Store assets: Who owns the shelving, display counters and equipment?

When a retailer closes a store, attention naturally turns to the stock.

But what about the shelving, display counters, refrigeration units, point-of-sale systems and other equipment used to operate the business?

Not everything inside a retail premises necessarily belongs to the retailer.

Some assets may be owned outright by the retailer. Others may be leased, financed or subject to security interests held by lenders or other third parties.

There is also the distinction between fixtures and chattels.

Depending on the degree and purpose of attachment to the premises, an item may become a fixture forming part of the land, rather than remain the tenant's removable property. This can affect who is entitled to remove it when a lease ends.

The lease provisions dealing with alterations, fixtures, fittings and make-good obligations are therefore particularly important.

For landlords, the practical concern is not just who owns the assets, but also who is responsible for removing them and restoring the premises to the required condition.

Where significant retail fit-outs are involved, the cost of reinstatement can be considerable.

What should commercial landlords and business owners review?

The David Jones situation highlights the importance of getting contractual protections right before financial difficulties arise.

For commercial landlords, consider reviewing:

  • Rent security: Are the bank guarantees or other security arrangements sufficient to cover the potential exposure?

  • Default provisions: What constitutes a breach, and what notice and remedy periods apply?

  • Insolvency provisions: How do the contractual rights interact with the statutory ipso facto regime?

  • Termination rights: When can the lease lawfully be terminated or possession recovered?

  • Make-good obligations: Are the tenant's obligations to remove, repair and reinstate the premises clearly documented?

For suppliers and other business owners, consider:

  • Retention of title: Do your supply agreements contain appropriately drafted ROT provisions?

  • PPSR registrations: Are your security interests properly registered and perfected?

  • Payment terms: Are credit limits and payment arrangements appropriate for the level of exposure?

  • Contractual remedies: Do your agreements provide appropriate rights to suspend supply, require payment or respond to financial distress?

It is also worth considering whether your business is overly reliant on a small number of major customers. A significant customer may represent valuable business, but it can also create considerable cash-flow exposure if that customer experiences financial difficulties.

Looking beyond the headlines

The outcome of David Jones' administration and receivership remains to be seen. Questions around the future of individual stores, the treatment of assets and the position of creditors will depend on the progress of the insolvency process.

For commercial landlords and business owners, however, the legal issues are already familiar.

A commercial lease is not just about rent and the right to occupy premises. A supply agreement is not just about delivering goods and getting paid. The real test of these arrangements often comes when one party can no longer meet its obligations.

Contractual protections are most valuable when things do not go according to plan.

At Alteris Legal, we advise on commercial property, leasing, transactions and contractual matters. If you are a commercial landlord, tenant or business owner looking to review your contractual arrangements, we welcome you to get in touch.

This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The application of insolvency laws and contractual rights will depend on the circumstances of each matter and the relevant agreements.

Date published: 6 November 2026

Share: