When a Head Lease Ends, What Happens to the Sublease? Lessons from a Victorian Supreme Court Decision
Written by
Samantha LoA settlement deed may restore a terminated head lease, but that does not necessarily restore the sublease or resolve the rights of the parties occupying the premises.
A recent decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria highlights the legal and commercial consequences that can follow when a commercial head lease is terminated, particularly where a subtenant is occupying the premises.
In KADS Warehousing & Logistics Pty Ltd v Tarantino Investments Pty Ltd [2026] VSC 676, the Court considered whether a landlord had affirmed a lease by continuing to invoice rent and outgoings after re-entry, the consequences of terminating the head lease for the sublease, and the effect of a subsequent settlement deed.
The decision offers several practical lessons for commercial landlords, head tenants and subtenants.
1. Does continuing to invoice rent mean the landlord has affirmed the lease?
The landlord terminated the head lease following the tenant's breach, having served a notice under section 146 of the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) and subsequently re-entered the premises.
However, the landlord continued issuing invoices for rent and outgoings.
The question was whether this conduct amounted to an election to affirm the lease, rather than rely on its termination.
The Court found that it did not.
The distinction was that the amounts invoiced were already owing. The landlord was pursuing an existing debt, rather than engaging in conduct inconsistent with its right to terminate the lease.
The practical point: Continuing to pursue outstanding rent and outgoings does not necessarily mean a landlord has elected to keep a lease alive. The nature of the payment claimed and the conduct relied upon must be considered in context.
2. What happens to the sublease when the head lease is terminated?
The Court found that the head lease had been validly terminated and that the sublease determined with it.
This is an important commercial risk for subtenants.
A subtenant's right to occupy the premises is generally derived from the head lease. If the head lease comes to an end, the subtenant may lose the contractual basis for its occupation, even where it has complied with its own obligations under the sublease.
For businesses operating from substantial commercial or industrial premises, this can have significant consequences, including disruption to operations, relocation costs and uncertainty about continued occupation.
The practical point: A subtenant should not assume that compliance with its sublease is enough to protect its occupation if the head tenant defaults under the head lease.
3. Can a settlement deed restore a terminated head lease?
The dispute did not end with the termination of the head lease.
The landlord and head tenant subsequently entered into a Deed of Settlement, which restored the previously terminated head lease.
However, this gave rise to a further period of disputes concerning possession, use and occupation compensation and trespass.
Importantly, the restoration of the head lease did not mean that the sublease had continued uninterrupted.
The Court considered the parties' rights to possession and found that the relevant entitlement arose only once the settlement deed restored the head lease.
This distinction matters. The legal position during the period following termination may be different from the position after a subsequent settlement or restoration.
The practical point: A settlement deed dealing with a terminated head lease should expressly address the position of any existing subtenant. It should not leave the parties to assume that the sublease has automatically resumed or that the previous occupation arrangements remain unchanged.
4. What about use and occupation compensation, trespass and the security deposit?
The Court also considered the consequences of occupation during the intervening period.
Claims for use and occupation compensation and trespass depend on the relevant party having possession or a right to possession. The Court's findings on when those rights arose were therefore significant.
The Court also considered the security deposit under the sublease. Its return was conditional on physical vacation of the premises, subject to an equitable set-off against the occupation compensation payable.
This highlights that the termination of a lease does not automatically resolve outstanding financial obligations between the parties.
The timing of vacation, the contractual conditions governing the security deposit and any outstanding occupation liabilities may all affect the final financial position.
5. What should commercial landlords, head tenants and subtenants take away?
The decision highlights the importance of addressing the consequences of termination before they become a larger dispute.
For landlords:
Be clear about whether you are pursuing existing rental arrears or engaging in conduct that may be inconsistent with termination.
Carefully document the steps taken to terminate the head lease and recover possession.
When negotiating a settlement, expressly address any sublease, occupation rights and outstanding financial obligations.
For head tenants:
Understand that a breach of the head lease can affect not only your own occupation rights but also the position of your subtenant.
Consider the consequences for existing subtenants before negotiating a settlement with the landlord.
Ensure that any settlement deed clearly deals with the restoration of the lease, possession and ongoing obligations.
For subtenants:
Consider the head lease's termination provisions and the circumstances in which the head lease may be brought to an end.
Seek appropriate protections in the sublease, including provisions dealing with the head tenant's default and the potential loss of occupation rights.
If the head lease is terminated and subsequently restored, obtain clarity on whether and how the sublease is to resume, including the terms of continued occupation.
Our takeaway
A terminated head lease, a sublease that has come to an end, and a subsequent settlement deed can create different legal positions across different periods.
The key lesson is that restoring the head lease does not necessarily resolve the position of the subtenant or undo everything that occurred during the intervening period.
For commercial landlords and tenants, these issues should be addressed expressly when drafting lease arrangements and negotiating settlement deeds, rather than left to implication.
At Alteris Legal, we assist landlords, tenants and businesses with commercial leasing, lease reviews, negotiations and disputes.
If you are entering into a commercial lease, dealing with a sublease or negotiating a lease termination, obtaining legal advice early can help identify risks before they become costly disputes.
This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The application of the law will depend on the circumstances of each matter.
Date published: 11 November 2026